Data Domain vs. Protectier

Where I am currently employed we are looking to replace our 3592 based library with a deduplication solution. Currently the higher ups are leaning towards IBM ProtecTIER without having thoroughly investigated any other solutions. Having previously used Data Domain solutions at my previous employ I was somewhat concerned that the ProtecTIER solution would be a bad fit for our environment. I have had some run ins with people who have used IBM's ProtecTIER solution and when compared to those who have used Data Domain (including myself) you immediately see the difference in how they talk about the two products. So I was hoping to find a good write-up showing in-depth details comparing the two solutions and it took a blogger like me to provide a great comparison.  If you would like a good overview of how Data Domain and ProtecTIER stack up against one another in technology and performance check out the following link. It's very informative and solidifies why I would prefer using Data Domain.

Deduplication: Data Domain Vs. ProtecTIER Performance

One item that was not covered was the NFS capabilities of both. While I used VTL functionality with Data Domain, I was a HUGE NFS proponent. You can save a lot of money over a TSM TDP + LAN-Free solution using NFS with 10Gb Ethernet for your DB backups  (since IBM's licensing costs are still questionable). When I was first exploring ProtecTIER they did not yet have NFS capabilities, so I'd like to see a NFS performance comparison between the two products.

TSM Server 5.5, 6.1, & 6.2 Bug

I figured I best share with you all a bug I have experienced with TSM Server version 6.2.2 that has resulted in the TSM instance core dumping. The problem stems from TSM being unable to mount a scratch tape with, in our case, a TSM storage agent. When the mount fails it seems TSM lists an internal server error then core dumps a few seconds later.  The fix is in 6.2.3 and higher. It also affects 5.5 and 6.1 versions, check this technote for further details.

Warning: This update has a bug also concerning Data Domain that causes errors if the defined VTL has more than 4400 slots. So when we upgraded the server to fix the LAN-Free bug we inadvertently encountered this bug.

Update: Here is the APAR listing for the Data Domain VTL slot bug in TSM 6.2.x